Cayman Islands court issues interim award in Algosaibi fraud case, orders Maan Al Sanea to pay US$2.5 billion
Source: AHAB , Author: Posted by BI-ME staff
Posted: Fri June 15, 2012 12:24 pm

INTERNATIONAL. The Grand Court of the Cayman Islands issued a ruling in favor of Ahmad Hamad Algosaibi & Brothers (AHAB) requiring Maan Al Sanea to pay AHAB US$2.5 billion, the amount requested by AHAB as an interim payment. 

In a 35-page ruling the Chief Justice found that AHAB would be entitled to recover at least 2.5 billion.

The Court's award was based on what it termed "compelling" evidence of "a pattern of massive payments to [Al Sanea's] Saad Group (at times running at an average of well over US$1 million per day)."   The Court found these payments, which were directed by Al-Sanea, to be "inexplicable having regard to the nature of AHAB's business" and declared that AHAB's allegations that Al-Sanea misappropriated billions of dollars were "now deemed proven against Mr. Al Sanea."

The ruling is a significant development in AHAB's recovery efforts against Maan Al Sanea, who is also currently being charged with financial crimes in Bahrain in relation to his massive fraud and is under investigation in Switzerland and the United States.

The ruling follows a default judgment entered against Al Sanea in November 2011. Under Cayman Islands procedure, the holder of default judgment may apply for an enforceable interim order for "a reasonable proportion of the damages which in the opinion of the Court are likely to be recovered."  

The ruling was based on the court's detailed review of the affidavit evidence of Simon Charlton, the Deloitte partner who led the forensic investigation. The ruling found that the specific forensic evidence of payments made from AHAB to Mr. Al Sanea and companies under his control "remains unchallenged." AHAB told the Court that it will undertake final quantification of their losses at the end of the case against Mr. Al Sanea and other parties on their claim. 

Although Mr. Al Sanea has repeatedly issued public statements denying AHAB's charges, he declined to submit any defense to AHAB's claims in the Cayman Court.  Instead, he unsuccessfully disputed the Cayman court's jurisdiction, losing in both the Cayman Islands Court of Appeal and Her Majesty's Privy Council in London, the final appellate court.

"Maan Al Sanea has repeatedly said he is waiting for his day in court to defend the charges against him.  Clearly, he has not and cannot," said Eric Lewis, AHAB's chief legal coordinator. "AHAB's forensic team provided compelling affidavit evidence of misappropriation. Mr. Al Sanea cannot defend the fraud charges on the merits and the court has acted accordingly. AHAB has requested at this juncture an order for US$2.5 billion to enable early action to be taken, but expects a significantly larger final award when this case is ultimately tried."

SOURCE:  Ahmad Hamad Algosaibi & Brothers (AHAB).

 

MIDDLE EAST BUSINESS COMMENT & ANALYSIS

date:Posted: July 25, 2014
UAE. Royal Decree amending some of the provisions of the Oman Agencies Law comes into force; Marks a significant departure from the regime under the old law.
date:Posted: July 24, 2014
UAE. There is evidence of a more litigious approach developing in the area of medical malpractice. Damages awards which have historically been low, are now on an upwards trend.
date:Posted: July 24, 2014
UAE. Report data shows that 64% of TV viewers in Saudi Arabia and 50% in the UAE are engaged in other digital activities simultaneously, higher than the global average.
INTERNATIONAL. U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry pressed regional proxies to nail down a Gaza ceasefire as the civilian death toll soared, threatening to spread Israeli-Palestinian bloodshed to the occupied West Bank and Jerusalem.
dhgate